Intelligence Report

Collective Health CEO says incumbents keep better benefits options from employers

At a Dallas digital health conference, benefits vendors described how insurer incentives, consultant economics and data fees shape what employers see.

INSIGHTEX Editorial Desk

2 min read

Collective Health CEO says incumbents keep better benefits options from employersIntelligence Report

What happened

Ali Diab, chief executive of independent benefits administration platform Collective Health, told a panel at the INVEST Digital Health conference in Dallas that economic incentives often stop self-insured employers from seeing the strongest benefits options, MedCity News reported. He named UnitedHealthcare and Cigna, saying his company cannot match the millions of dollars in transition credits that large insurers and administrators use to fend off rivals.

Diab also argued that consulting firms earn substantial revenue from pharmacy benefit manager contracts. In his view, this helps explain why transparent PBM options rarely surface when employers rebid those contracts each year, and a similar dynamic affects third-party administrators and specialized point solutions. He added that incumbent insurers charge fees such as $10,000 or $15,000 when smaller vendors ask for claims files to analyze.

Other panelists focused on proving value. Julie Stadlbauer, chief development officer of Progyny, said a third-party claims data analysis commissioned by one employer found that the company's fertility benefits program saved it $32 million over seven years. Jason Tibbels, chief medical officer of Lantern Health, said vendors must satisfy both employers and employees. He cited a surgical complication rate below 1% and suggested AI could fill in details employers already hold, sparing workers repetitive forms.

Context

Employer-sponsored health insurance covered about 165 million Americans in 2023. Investor Mark Cuban regularly uses X to press self-insured employers to examine their PBM contracts, and he launched Cost Plus Wellness to push for transparency. Several bills aim to break up firms that combine payer, provider, PBM and pharmacy businesses, and CVS recently split in two.

SourceMedCity News

The briefing

The week in tech, in one email.

The stories worth your time, every week. Unsubscribe anytime.