What happened
Public school systems in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago are exploring replacements for Google Search after the company said schools that switch off its AI tools would also lose Search, The Verge reported, citing The New York Times. From next year, schools will no longer be able to turn off Gemini-powered features while keeping Search available.
According to the Times, Google education vice president Chris Phillips said the company's search and AI products are tightly linked and that schools disabling the AI features would lose Search. Kamar H. Samuels, chancellor of the New York City school system, said the city would look at other search providers unless Google changed course, and Chicago's district reportedly told Google it would seek other options if no AI-free Search was offered.
Several elected figures, among them Senator Bernie Sanders and New York City's mayor, Zohran Mamdani, described Google's approach as extortion. Google spokesperson Laura Breen told The Verge the company shares educators' concerns, is piloting step-by-step Guided Learning in Search this month, and will next year make the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search off by default until schools choose to enable them.
Context
Educators have raised concerns about AI's effect on students' critical thinking, and some studies have found that students who use AI tend to score worse on tests. There are also worries about young children forming relationships with chatbots. Mamdani had recently announced a policy limiting classroom AI use, while Google remains deeply embedded in US schools through Google Classroom and Chromebooks, making a full exit difficult.
El boletín
La semana tecnológica, en un solo correo.
Las crónicas que merecen su tiempo, cada semana. Cancele la suscripción cuando quiera.
